NSCDC Custody Deaths: Panel Indicts Officers, Recommends ₦1.4bn Compensation

NSCDC Custody Deaths: Panel Indicts Officers, Recommends ₦1.4bn Compensation

A Federal Government investigative committee has released its report on the deaths of 33 detainees, including 14 minors, in the custody of the Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps in Niger State, attributing the tragedy to severe overcrowding, suffocation, poor ventilation and negligence by officers responsible for their welfare.

The committee recommended the prosecution and dismissal of culpable personnel, compensation totalling ₦1.4bn for affected families and survivors, and comprehensive reforms of the NSCDC’s detention and operational procedures.

The findings were presented in Abuja by the chairman of the 10-member Independent Investigative Committee and former Deputy Director-General of the Department of State Services, Jonathan Kure, to the Minister of Interior, Olubunmi Tunji-Ojo.

Interior Minister Olubunmi Tunji-Ojo receives investigative committee report on the deaths of 33 detainees in NSCDC custody in Niger State.
Members of the Independent Investigative Committee with the Minister of Interior, Olubunmi Tunji-Ojo, in Abuja.

The committee was constituted following a directive by President Bola Tinubu to investigate the circumstances surrounding the deaths of persons arrested during operations against suspected illegal mining activities in Niger State.

Although earlier reports indicated that 37 detainees had died, the committee said it authenticated 33 deaths, including those of 14 minors, and identified 41 survivors.

Kure described the incident as an entirely preventable custodial tragedy arising from unlawful detention conditions, failure of duty of care, inadequate supervision and disregard for repeated distress warnings.

According to him, medical and forensic investigations established that the victims died from environmental asphyxia caused by prolonged confinement in a severely overcrowded and poorly ventilated detention facility.

The committee identified heat stress, dehydration and inadequate access to basic necessities as additional factors that contributed to the deaths.

It rejected suggestions that the deaths resulted from an infectious disease outbreak, stating that available medical and forensic evidence did not support such claims.

Unauthorised Raids, Overcrowded Detention Facility

The investigation established that NSCDC personnel conducted operations against suspected illegal mining activities in Niger State on September 15 and 16 without an approved operational order, adequate planning or proper consultation with relevant mining authorities.

The committee also found that the corps’ national headquarters was not informed before the operations commenced.

The suspects were reportedly arrested during raids around the M.I. Wushishi and Lukoto areas of Niger State and subsequently taken into custody at the NSCDC Niger State Command in Minna.

According to the report, approximately 50 male detainees were confined in a cell measuring about 20 square metres.

The facility lacked adequate ventilation, running water, proper lighting and a functioning toilet.

Investigators further discovered that food and drinking water were either unavailable or grossly inadequate throughout the period of detention.

The committee also established that adults and minors were detained together without adequate safeguards for the protection of children.

Kure said the conditions violated constitutional protections, provisions of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act, the Child Rights Act and accepted international standards governing the treatment of persons in custody.

The panel maintained that the conditions were unsuitable for human detention and exposed the suspects to severe physical distress.

Detainees Cried for Help Before Deaths

The investigative committee disclosed that witnesses described desperate attempts by detainees to attract the attention of officers as conditions inside the cell deteriorated.

According to the witnesses, the detainees repeatedly banged on the cell doors and walls, shouted for assistance and pleaded for drinking water.

Despite these warnings, officers responsible for their welfare allegedly failed to open the cell, reduce overcrowding or arrange emergency medical intervention.

Kure said the evidence indicated that the officers had sufficient warning that the detention conditions had become life-threatening but failed to take appropriate action.

The committee established that the deaths occurred between 8pm on September 16 and 7am on September 17, when the cell was eventually opened.

It concluded that timely intervention, adequate ventilation, access to water and proper detention procedures could have prevented the tragedy.

Forensic Findings, Missing Records Raise Concerns

The committee disclosed that post-mortem examinations were conducted on three bodies, while the remaining 30 victims had already been buried before its medical team arrived.

Investigators found no evidence supporting allegations that an aerosol substance had been sprayed into the detention cell before the deaths.

However, the panel raised concerns about possible interference with evidence at the facility.

It established that the detention area had been cleaned, disinfected and altered before independent forensic investigators arrived.

The committee also reported that the detention register for September 16 was unavailable, creating additional difficulties in reconstructing the events surrounding the deaths.

These findings prompted recommendations for further investigations into possible concealment, destruction or alteration of evidence.

Panel Indicts NSCDC Commandant, Other Officers

The committee identified leadership failures, professional misconduct and serious breaches of responsibility among personnel involved in the operations and detention of the suspects.

Those implicated included the Niger State NSCDC Commandant, the Head of the Investigation Unit and other officers responsible for the detainees’ welfare.

According to the report, the state commandant authorised and supervised the operation without adequate planning, coordination or oversight.

The panel also accused the commandant of permitting overcrowded detention conditions and subsequently attributing the deaths to a disease outbreak.

Other officers were accused of failing to respond to repeated distress calls, maintaining unlawful detention conditions and detaining minors without appropriate protection.

Some personnel were further implicated in the alteration of the detention facility before forensic investigators arrived.

The committee concluded that these failures reflected wider institutional weaknesses in the corps’ operational supervision, detention management and accountability mechanisms.

Committee Recommends Prosecution, Dismissal

Following its findings, the committee recommended criminal prosecution of culpable officers for offences including murder, criminal negligence, torture and inhuman treatment, where supported by the evidence and applicable laws.

It also called for further investigations into allegations of extortion and mismanagement of exhibits connected with the operations.

The panel recommended the summary dismissal of the state commandant and officers found directly responsible for the deaths.

It further proposed administrative sanctions against other personnel whose actions or omissions contributed to the tragedy.

The recommendations, however, remain subject to the relevant legal and disciplinary processes.

₦1.4bn Compensation Proposed for Families, Survivors

Beyond criminal and administrative sanctions, the committee proposed a compensation package of ₦1.4bn for the families of the deceased and survivors.

Under the recommendation, each of the 33 bereaved families would receive ₦30m, amounting to ₦990m.

The 41 survivors would receive ₦10m each, bringing their proposed compensation to ₦410m.

Together, the payments would amount to ₦1.4bn.

The committee also recommended educational support for dependants of the deceased, medical rehabilitation for survivors and psychological assistance for affected families.

It called on the Federal Government to issue a formal apology to the victims’ families and survivors.

The proposed payments have not been confirmed as approved or disbursed.

Panel Seeks Overhaul of NSCDC Operations

The committee called for comprehensive institutional reforms to prevent similar tragedies in detention facilities operated by the NSCDC.

Its recommendations included the establishment of standard detention facilities with adequate ventilation, sanitation and access to essential services.

It also proposed the installation of closed-circuit television cameras in custodial areas to strengthen monitoring, transparency and accountability.

Other recommendations included improved emergency medical response, stronger supervisory mechanisms and enhanced human rights training for personnel.

The committee emphasised the need for operational discipline, proper documentation of arrests and detention, and compliance with legal safeguards protecting suspects.

It maintained that detention facilities must operate under conditions consistent with human dignity and the constitutional rights of individuals, regardless of the offences they are suspected of committing.

Interior Minister Promises Justice

Receiving the report, the Minister of Interior, Olubunmi Tunji-Ojo, assured the committee that the Federal Government would act on its recommendations and ensure accountability for the deaths.

The minister directed the NSCDC Commandant-General to immediately suspend officers allegedly involved in cleaning the detention facility and potentially destroying evidence.

He stressed that justice for the victims must remain the government’s priority.

“The best gift we can give to the deceased is justice. And justice must be done,” Tunji-Ojo declared.

The minister said the report would be forwarded to the Office of the Attorney-General of the Federation and Minister of Justice for further legal consideration and possible prosecution.

He added that the Ministry of Interior would examine the administrative recommendations and work with the NSCDC to implement necessary institutional reforms.

Tunji-Ojo also warned that officers implicated in concealing or destroying evidence would face suspension pending investigations and disciplinary proceedings.

He maintained that the government would not treat the committee’s findings as a mere administrative exercise intended to reduce public pressure.

The minister reaffirmed the Federal Government’s commitment to ensuring that the circumstances surrounding the deaths were thoroughly addressed.

Committee Member Raises Concern Over Report

Meanwhile, a member of the investigative committee, Deji Adeyanju, raised concerns during the presentation over what he described as the removal of a section from the report’s executive summary.

Adeyanju alleged that the section had been included when the committee concluded its work but was missing from the version presented to the minister.

He called for its restoration and questioned whether references to the NSCDC Commandant-General had been removed.

However, speaking to journalists after the presentation, Adeyanju clarified that he had reviewed the full report and confirmed that the disputed section remained in the main document.

He reiterated his concern that the victims should receive justice and that the investigation must produce meaningful consequences.

“I don’t want these people to die in vain,” he said.

Deaths Renew Concerns Over Custodial Accountability

The findings have brought renewed attention to the treatment of suspects in security agencies’ custody, particularly the detention of minors, overcrowding and the responsibility of officers to protect detainees from preventable harm.

The investigation also raises questions about operational authorisation, supervision and the preservation of evidence following deaths in custody.

The committee’s findings distinguish the deaths from the original allegations of illegal mining that led to the arrests, establishing that the circumstances of detention were central to the tragedy.

The victims died while being held at the NSCDC Niger State Command in Minna after operations targeting suspected illegal mining activities.

With the report now submitted to the Federal Government, attention turns to the implementation of its recommendations, the possible prosecution of implicated officers and the proposed compensation for affected families and survivors.

The committee’s findings also place responsibility on the authorities to ensure that the recommended reforms translate into measurable improvements in detention conditions, operational oversight and the protection of fundamental human rights.

Source: Punch

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *